L'anatra Pizza and Kitchen - Selden, New York

Gallaad Jean-Louis

I walk in while it’s dead, guy sitting down on his phone with an apron on tells me if I want to use the bathroom I have to purchase something.

I purchase an over priced drink, use the restroom, and out the drink back in the fridge. God bless, hope your business does well, upgrade your employees with better judgement, and step up your customer service.

12/28/24

Tara K

Slices was taken over by L'anatra, so we decided to try take out. I started with a spinach roll, which was generously stuffed. I ordered the Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Panuozzo with fresh mozzarella. It was excellent! My husband ordered the Steak Pannini and enjoyed it. He also ordered an eggplant parmagiana hero, which was perfectly crisp and well done. The menu offers a variety of different pizza options, and we are looking forward to trying them. Delivery was estimated at 30-40 minutes, but arrived just past an hour. No big deal, as the food was hot.

stephen thelemon

The man at the counter was super nice when taking my order even though he was by himself working on other orders, then once I got my food I was really impressed, the Sicilian slices are crunchy yet fluffy, the plain slices are thin and crisp yet flavorful, and the garlic knots are perfectly seasoned. Not to mention they serve cannoli stuffed zeppoles, definitely give this place a shot if, like me, you've been a bit disappointed with the usual spots! Pizza is an 8.3 easy, everybody knows the rules!

Sahan Perera

We happened to be in the neighborhood and randomly stopped at this pizza shop for a slice few weeks ago and we were so glad we did. Since then I and wife said let’s visit this pizza shop whenever we are in this neighborhood:) .
So today we made our second visit for a proper sit down pizza lunch.
I am a big fan of simple pepperoni pizza and their’s is one of the best I have had in a long time. Crust is perfectly done, thin and crispy on the side and perfectly holds all the ingredients without falling off the slice. Tomato source is very tasty as it supposed to be and I could tell someone really knows how to do it and is doing it right. Try their garlic knots which are delicious as well, I could taste fresh garlic and herbs. After being satisfied with our lunch we wanted to thank the pizza chef.. and had opportunity to speak the Gentlemen with a big smile and very friendly.. who is named Frank, who is from Sicily with beautiful Italian accent. He gave us a brief introduction of his background from Sicily and took us on a verbal virtual tour around Sicily. After met and got to know him I am not surprised they have such tasty Italian dishes.
Thank you Frank and the team. Keep up the good work and good luck.

Jenny S

First time ; we had a Buffalo chicken slice and una fetta con anatra (slice with duck). Both were tasty.
Impressed by : the generosity of the cheese and meats . The Buffalo slice actually seemed to have shredded chicken breast rather than that rib meat garbage the other local pizzerias use. Also good - The quality of all the ingredients in comparison to other local pizzerias.
Surprised by: I didn’t realize they were open as long as they have been (acc to the reviews here) as it seemed like they looked fairly new inside & somewhat even unfinished.
Let’s get back to what’s important… flavors. These people know flavors. Anyone who doesn’t appreciate that should stick to every other inconsistent , tasteless place in our area because your bars are programmed to be too low. We need flavors & creativity around here in the most desperate way so please owners don’t change , just keep improving and I hope you stick around. I’m excited to try other things on the menu.

Alexis C

The girls working the counter need to do more training bc they don’t know how to do their jobs whatsoever. We called because they forgot half of our order and they laughed about it on the phone. We went to pick it up which is an inconvenience in itself coming back for the second time and they tried to make us pay again for their mistake. This isn’t the first time they messed up our order but it will definitely be the last. Never again. It’s a shame bc the pizza is great.

Tanas World

BEST SPOT EVER! Delicious food! Amazing Atmosphere! And a fantastic owner & staff! I always have a great time every time I walk into L’anatra Pizza ? My top favorite slices are the margarita & Vodka margarita it is to die for. But! That upside down slice is soo damn good And it’s a different sauce A little bit sweeter, but that’s exactly what I like! You need to try their Cannoli filled Zeppolis. If you have a sweet tooth, that is literally the best fix for that. The garlic knots are perfect and not Extremely soaked like most places aka (cafe amici). And in my opinion, you really have to try the espresso I’m not somebody who likes coffee or even that taste But the Macchiato espresso Is just perfectly sweet for me. Overall, the best experience ever I don’t wanna go anywhere else you gotta come here and bring your people they gonna love it to

Sara Tramazzo

This place is incredible! I have never had such a great customer service experience at a pizza place. I went a few days ago and loved the atmosphere and how friendly the man at the counter was. I had a delicious vodka margarita slice with mozzarella they make in-house!! Yesterday my boyfriend and I had a late night and needed a place open late to grab food. I remembered this place had a sign that they were open til 1 am (thank god, all the pizza places around here close so early!!) so we stopped by at around 12:30. They were clearly wrapping up after a slow night, but the owner was accommodating and encouraged us to let him make us some fresh specialty pizza! He made us half buffalo and half vodka margarita, and one regular slice - all fresh. He was super cool and friendly the whole time - which has been my opposite experience at the other local pizza places where I feel like it's very fast paced, unfriendly, and dudes just yelling "next!"
All the pizza was incredible, including the garlic knots. This place just feels like a good old pizza joint with guys who like.. care about pizza lol. I will be a returning customer! 🙂